Walmart vs Amazon Affiliate: Which Pays More?

Walmart vs Amazon Affiliate: Which Pays More?

Walmart vs Amazon Affiliate: Which Pays More?

Stuck between Amazon and Walmart for your affiliate marketing journey? While Amazon's got that massive reach and killer conversion rates, Walmart's higher commissions might surprise you. Let's explore which retail giant could be your perfect money-making partner.

·

Nov 14, 2024

Walmart vs Amazon Affiliate: Which Pays More?

/

Table of Contents

Looking to boost your online income?

The choice between Walmart and Amazon's affiliate programs might just be your next big decision.

While both retail giants offer exciting opportunities, they each bring something unique to the table.

Amazon's built a reputation for converting clicks into sales like nobody's business.

Their massive product selection and customer trust make them a go-to choice for many affiliates.

But don't count Walmart out - their higher commission rates in certain categories could mean more money in your pocket, especially if you're focusing on electronics or home goods.

Let's break down what makes each program tick, so you can make the best choice for your business.

The Big Picture: Walmart vs Amazon Affiliates

You've got two retail powerhouses offering you a chance to earn by promoting their products. Both programs are free to join and come packed with tools to help you succeed.

Walmart's affiliate program lets you tap into their extensive product catalog while earning up to 4% on sales.

They provide you with everything you need to get started - from eye-catching banners to useful widgets that showcase products on your site.

Amazon Associates takes a different approach.

Their commissions range from 1% to 10%, depending on what you're promoting.

They've mastered the art of conversion, and their toolkit includes detailed reporting features that help you understand exactly what's working (and what's not) in your promotional strategy.

Each platform serves different audiences and shopping behaviors. Amazon excels at quick, trust-based purchases, while Walmart often appeals to value-conscious shoppers who compare prices across platforms.

Making Money: Breaking Down the Numbers

Let's talk about what really matters - how much you can earn.

Both platforms structure their commissions differently, and knowing these details can seriously impact your earning potential.

Walmart keeps things straightforward with their commission structure.

You'll earn 4% on most categories - think clothing, toys, home goods, and beauty products.

Electronics come in at 1%, which makes sense given their typically tighter margins.

One sweet spot? Baby gear nets you 4%, making it a solid choice if you're running a parenting blog or website.

Here's something worth noting: Walmart gives you a 3-day window to earn commissions after someone clicks your link. That means if your reader clicks today but buys three days later, you're still getting paid.

This longer cookie duration gives you a better chance of earning from comparison shoppers who take their time making decisions.

Amazon takes a more varied approach to commissions.

They've set up different rates based on what you're selling:

  • Beauty products in their luxury category can earn you a nice 10%

  • Home and garden items bring in 8%

  • Fresh groceries net 3%

  • Gaming products sit at 1%

But there's a catch - Amazon's cookie only lasts 24 hours.

This means you need to focus on products people tend to buy quickly rather than items that usually require more consideration time.

Smart Money Moves

Your earning potential really comes down to matching your content with the right products.

Got a home improvement blog? Walmart's flat 4% on furniture might work better than Amazon's 8% if your readers tend to be price-conscious and Walmart offers better deals.

Running a luxury beauty blog? Amazon's 10% commission on high-end beauty products could be your golden ticket.

Product Selection: Finding Your Sweet Spot

Let's dig into what you can actually sell on these platforms - because having the right products for your audience makes all the difference.

Amazon's Product Universe

Amazon's product selection is massive - and that's putting it mildly.

They've got pretty much everything under the sun, from rare collectibles to everyday essentials. This variety gives you tons of flexibility when you're creating content.

Say you're running a tech review site - you can promote the latest gadgets alongside their accessories and complementary products.

Or maybe you've got a cooking blog - you can link to unique kitchen tools, specialty ingredients, and even digital cookbooks, all from the same platform.

Walmart's Product Power

While Walmart might not match Amazon's sheer number of products, they excel in specific areas that could work perfectly for your audience.

Their strength lies in everyday essentials, home goods, and family-focused products.

If your content covers topics like home organization, family budgeting, or affordable fashion, Walmart's selection hits the sweet spot of quality and value.

Digital vs Physical Products

One key difference worth noting: Amazon has a strong game in digital products. If you talk about books, music, or streaming content, Amazon gives you more options with their Kindle books, Prime Video, and digital services.

Walmart focuses mainly on physical products, though they're expanding their digital offerings.

Finding Your Niche Match

Let's put this into perspective with some real examples:

  • Parent bloggers might find Walmart's baby gear selection and competitive pricing perfect for their audience. Plus, that 4% commission rate on baby products beats Amazon's lower rates in the same category.

  • Tech reviewers could benefit from both platforms - use Amazon for the latest gadgets and rare finds, while featuring Walmart for budget-friendly alternatives and mainstream electronics.

  • Lifestyle content creators can mix and match. Amazon's wider selection works great for unique finds and specialty items, while Walmart's pricing on everyday items can appeal to budget-conscious followers.

Tools and Tech: Making Your Life Easier

Both Walmart and Amazon want you to succeed - after all, your success is their success. Let's look at the tools they provide to help you make those sales happen.

Amazon's Toolkit

Amazon's really nailed the ease-of-use factor with their tools.

Their SiteStripe feature is a game-changer - it lets you create affiliate links right from any Amazon page you're browsing.

No more copying and pasting product codes or juggling multiple windows.

They also give you the Amazon Associates WordPress Plugin, which makes life so much simpler if you're running a WordPress site.

Drop product links and images into your posts with just a few clicks. Even better, these links automatically update with current prices and availability.

For data lovers, Amazon's reporting tools show you exactly what's working.

You can track which products your audience clicks on most, what they end up buying (even if it's different from what they clicked), and which content drives the most sales.

Walmart's Arsenal

Walmart takes a slightly different approach with their tools.

Their Associate Program focuses on giving you flexibility in how you present products.

You get access to clean, professional-looking banners that match your site's style, and their product links are simple to generate and use.

Their tracking system shows you the basics - clicks, sales, and commissions. While not as detailed as Amazon's analytics, it gives you the essential data needed to track your performance.

One standout feature is their API access. If you're tech-savvy or work with a developer, you can create custom integrations that match your site's unique needs.

Making the Most of Your Tools

Here's what works well: Use Amazon's SiteStripe for quick links when writing product reviews or comparison posts. The instant link generation saves tons of time.

Take advantage of Walmart's customizable banners for seasonal promotions - they work great for holiday gift guides or special sale events.

Use both platforms' reporting tools to understand your audience better. Notice they're buying lots of kitchen gadgets? That might signal an opportunity to create more cooking-related content.

Converting Clicks to Cash: What Really Works

The real money in affiliate marketing isn't just about getting clicks - it's about turning those clicks into actual purchases.

Let's see how these two giants stack up when it comes to converting your audience into buyers.

Amazon's Conversion Magic

Ask any experienced affiliate marketer about Amazon's conversion rates, and you'll likely see a smile. Amazon has mastered the art of turning browsers into buyers.

Their well-oiled machine includes:

  • One-click purchasing

  • Prime shipping benefits

  • A trusted review system

  • Product recommendations that actually make sense

Think about it - when someone clicks your Amazon link, they're entering a shopping environment they already know and trust.

Many already have their payment info saved and Prime shipping set up. That familiarity often leads to higher conversion rates.

Walmart's Growing Edge

Walmart's online presence keeps getting stronger. While they might not match Amazon's conversion rates yet, they've got some compelling advantages:

  • Competitive pricing that often beats Amazon

  • The option to pick up items in-store (perfect for immediate needs)

  • Free shipping on many items

  • Price matching that builds customer confidence

The Cookie Clock: Timing Matters Here's where things get interesting. Walmart gives you a 3-day cookie window - meaning if someone clicks your link, you've got three full days to earn a commission if they make a purchase. That's perfect for:

  • Big-ticket items where people need time to decide

  • Products that require comparison shopping

  • Items people might want to discuss with family members first

Amazon's 24-hour cookie might seem short in comparison, but it works well with their impulse-buy friendly platform. Your strategy needs to match this timing - focus on products people are ready to buy now rather than ones that need lots of research.

Smart Strategy Tips

Match your content to these conversion patterns. For Amazon links, create content that encourages immediate action - think "best deals today" or "solving immediate problems."

For Walmart, you can take a more considered approach, especially for higher-priced items where people appreciate having time to think.

Getting Started: Your Path to Affiliate Success

Starting your affiliate journey with either platform is pretty straightforward, but there are some key differences worth knowing about.

Let's walk through exactly what you need to do to get up and running.

Starting with Amazon Associates

Getting started with Amazon is pretty straightforward. They've streamlined their process to get you earning quickly:

First, head to the Amazon Associates homepage and click that sign-up button. Already have an Amazon account? Perfect - use those same login details. If not, you'll create one first.

Now comes the important part. Amazon wants to know about your online presence, so be ready to share:

  • Your website or social media channels

  • How you build traffic

  • The types of content you create

  • Your plans for promoting products

Here's a pro tip: Be specific when describing your promotion methods. Instead of saying "I'll post links," explain how you'll create detailed product reviews, comparison guides, or how-to content that naturally incorporates product recommendations.

Starting with Walmart's Program

Walmart's signup process feels a bit more traditional but still straightforward. They're particularly interested in understanding how you'll represent their brand.

Visit Walmart's affiliate page and fill out their application.

You'll need to share:

  • Your website details

  • Traffic sources

  • Marketing strategies

  • Typical monthly visitors

Getting Approved

What to Know

Both platforms typically review applications within 24 hours, but here's what helps you get the green light:

  • Have some content already published

  • Show a clear plan for how you'll promote products

  • Demonstrate professional presentation

  • Keep your site free from controversial content

Quick Tip: If you're just starting out, focus on building quality content first. Both platforms want to see that you're creating value for your audience, not just throwing up product links.

Getting Paid: Understanding Your Money Flow

Let's talk about everyone's favorite part - getting paid for your hard work. Both platforms have different ways of handling payments, and knowing these details helps you plan your affiliate business better.

Amazon's Payment Options

Amazon gives you several ways to collect your earnings. Here's what works best in different situations:

  • Direct Deposit: Most affiliates choose this option because it's fast and free. Once you hit $10 in earnings, Amazon automatically sends money to your bank account. It's perfect if you want a hands-off payment system.

  • Amazon Gift Cards: Also available at the $10 mark, this option might work if you regularly shop on Amazon yourself. Some affiliates use this to reinvest in products for review content.

  • Check Payments: While available, they come with two catches - a higher minimum payout of $100 and a $15 processing fee. Unless you really need a paper check, the other options make more sense.

Walmart's Payment Structure

Walmart keeps things simpler with direct deposit as their main payment method. You'll need to earn $50 before getting paid, which might take longer when you're starting out.

The good news?

Once you hit that threshold, payments roll in monthly like clockwork.

Smart Money Management Tips

Track your earnings across both platforms carefully. Amazon's 60-day payment schedule means commissions from January sales arrive in March. Same with Walmart - they pay on a similar timeline.

Plan around these payment schedules:

  • Use Amazon's lower payout threshold ($10) to get paid sooner when starting out

  • Consider Walmart's higher commission rates on certain categories to hit their $50 threshold faster

  • Keep detailed records of earnings from both platforms to forecast your income

Quick tip: Set up direct deposit right away with both platforms. It's the fastest, most reliable way to get your money, and you'll avoid any processing fees or delays.

Making Your Choice: The Real Deal on Both Programs

Let's cut through the noise and look at what really matters when choosing between these platforms. Rather than a simple pros and cons list, let's explore how each platform's strengths and limitations might affect your success.

Amazon's Strong Points

Amazon's biggest advantage sits right in your audience's comfort zone. People trust Amazon - they're already there, credit cards saved, Prime memberships active. This translates into some serious benefits for you:

  • Brand Trust: When you share an Amazon link, you're tapping into years of built-up customer trust. Your readers already know what to expect from the shopping experience.

  • Product Selection: Need to recommend something super specific? Amazon probably has it. This flexibility lets you create highly targeted content without worrying about product availability.

  • Easy Integration: Their tools make it simple to add links and product showcases to your content. The SiteStripe tool alone can save you hours of work each week.

Where Amazon Could Do Better

  • Commission Rates: Recent changes have brought down earnings in several categories. That 1-3% on electronics can feel pretty thin when you're promoting high-value items.

  • Short Cookie Window: That 24-hour tracking period means you might miss out on sales from comparison shoppers who take their time.

Walmart's Winning Features

  • Higher Commissions: Their steady 4% rate across many categories can mean better earnings, especially on higher-priced items like furniture or baby gear.

  • Less Competition: Fewer affiliates mean your content might stand out more easily in certain niches.

  • Local Advantage: That mix of online shopping with local pickup options gives you unique angles for your content, especially for immediate-need items.

Walmart's Growing Edges

  • Online Presence: While improving rapidly, they're still building up their online shopping experience to match Amazon's smoothness.

  • Tool Limitations: Their affiliate tools work well but don't offer quite as many features as Amazon's suite.

Many successful affiliates use both programs strategically:

  • Use Amazon for specialty items and products needing detailed reviews

  • Promote Walmart for everyday essentials and price-conscious recommendations

  • Match each platform's strengths to different content types

This way, you're not leaving money on the table, and you're giving your audience options that fit their shopping preferences.

Looking Ahead

Success in affiliate marketing isn't just about choosing between Walmart and Amazon - it's about using both platforms strategically to serve your audience while growing your income.

Stay flexible, keep testing new approaches, and always focus on providing value to your readers.

Remember: The best platform is often both platforms, used strategically to give your audience options while maximizing your earning potential.

Michael Leander

Michael Leander

Michael Leander

Senior Marketing Consultant

Michael Leander is an experienced digital marketer and an online solopreneur.

More in

eCommerce

trends

Load More

A monthly post delivered straight to your inbox

Zero spam, just the good stuff

A monthly post delivered straight to your inbox

Zero spam, just the good stuff

A monthly post delivered straight to your inbox

Zero spam, just the good stuff