Uber Eats Pros and Cons: For Customers, Drivers & Restaurants

Uber Eats Pros and Cons: For Customers, Drivers & Restaurants

Uber Eats Pros and Cons: For Customers, Drivers & Restaurants

Considering Uber Eats? Honest assessment of driver pay, flexibility, and challenges, plus customer costs and service quality insights.

·

Nov 14, 2024

Table of Contents

Uber Eats has transformed the way we get food delivered, but its impact varies greatly depending on whether you're ordering dinner, delivering it, or serving it up. 

I've spent years tracking the food delivery space, and let me tell you - there's more than meets the eye when it comes to this popular platform.

Operating in over 6,000 cities globally, Uber Eats connects hungry customers with local restaurants through a simple app interface. 

But behind that sleek design lies a complex web of benefits and drawbacks that affect everyone differently.

Let's break down what Uber Eats really means for customers craving convenience, drivers seeking flexible income, and restaurants trying to expand their reach.

What Customers Need to Know About Uber Eats

If you're considering ordering through Uber Eats, you're probably weighing convenience against cost. 

Here's what you should know before placing your next order.

The Good Stuff for Customers

Doorstep delivery on demand is Uber Eats' main selling point. 

You can browse countless local restaurants from your couch and have food arrive without changing out of your pajamas. 

This convenience factor skyrocketed during pandemic lockdowns when many of us relied on delivery services to stay safely fed.

Restaurant options galore make Uber Eats appealing for the indecisive. 

With over 825,000 restaurant partners worldwide by 2022, you can discover new local spots or order from familiar favorites. 

Even smaller towns typically have decent options available.

The live tracking feature lets you monitor your meal's journey from kitchen to doorstep, eliminating the mystery of "where's my food?" 

And features like scheduled deliveries and contactless drop-off add flexibility to the experience. 

If you use Uber Eats regularly, their Uber One membership can save you money by eliminating delivery fees on orders over $15.

Regular promotions help offset some costs. 

First-time users often get special discounts, and the platform frequently offers deals like free delivery or percentage discounts on specific restaurants. 

If you keep an eye out for promo codes, you can sometimes score significant savings.

Cashless payment streamlines the whole process. 

Everything happens in-app – payment, tipping, and receipts – so there's no fumbling for cash when your food arrives. 

The app also makes reordering favorites quick and painless.

The Not-So-Good Stuff for Customers

Those fees add up fast. Between service fees, delivery charges, and suggested tips, your total can balloon by 20-30% or more. 

According to a study by Forbes, delivery apps sometimes charge up to 91% more than ordering directly, with Uber Eats among the highest markups. 

One Reddit user reported paying $32 in fees and tip on a $68 order – that's nearly a 50% markup just for convenience.

Delivery times aren't always reliable. During peak hours, bad weather, or driver shortages, your food might arrive significantly later than estimated. 

There's also the risk of missing or incorrect items, which can be particularly frustrating when you're hungry and looking forward to a specific dish.

Food quality can suffer in transit. That perfectly crispy fried chicken might arrive soggy after a 20-minute journey. 

If your driver makes multiple stops or takes an inefficient route, your meal might be cold by the time it reaches you. 

And unlike in a restaurant, you can't immediately address quality issues face-to-face.

Menu prices are often higher than what you'd pay in the restaurant. 

Many establishments raise their app prices to offset Uber Eats' commission fees. 

So that $10 burger in-store might cost $12-15 on the app – before adding all those extra fees and tip.

App reliability isn't guaranteed. Like any technology, Uber Eats can experience crashes or glitches, particularly during high-volume times like major sporting events or holidays.

If the app goes down mid-order, you might be left hungry or even double-charged until the issue resolves.

The Driver Experience: Flexibility vs. Stability

Driving for Uber Eats has become a popular side hustle or full-time gig for many.

But is it worth getting behind the wheel? Let's look at both sides.

What Drivers Love About Uber Eats

Set your own schedule with no minimum hour requirements. 

This flexibility is the top reason many people choose gig driving, especially students, parents, or anyone needing to work around other commitments. 

You can go online when you want and log off when you're done – no boss to check in with.

Get paid quickly through Uber's Instant Pay feature, which allows drivers to cash out earnings up to 5 times daily for a small fee. 

This immediate access to earnings is a major advantage for those needing fast cash.

Earning potential can be decent during busy periods. 

While base pay per delivery is low ($2-4 typically), drivers keep 100% of tips, which can significantly boost income. 

With strategic timing and location choices, hourly earnings can average $12-20+ during peak times. Business Insider reported that tips actually make up over 50% of delivery drivers' income.

Low entry barriers make Uber Eats accessible to many people who might struggle with traditional employment. 

You don't need special licenses or extensive experience – just a functional vehicle (car, bike, or scooter in many cities), a smartphone, and the ability to pass a basic background check. 

There's no formal interview process, making it an option for those who prefer minimal social interaction.

Work environment variety keeps things interesting.

Unlike office jobs, delivery driving offers constantly changing scenery, routes, and brief interactions. 

Many drivers appreciate the solitude of being on the road, listening to music or podcasts while earning money.

What Makes Drivers Think Twice

Base pay is remarkably low. Without tips, the economics of Uber Eats driving quickly fall apart. 

There's no hourly minimum wage protection or guaranteed income – if it's slow, you might make next to nothing despite being available for hours. 

The food delivery driver earnings study revealed that 53.4% of driver earnings came from tips, highlighting just how little the base pay contributes.

Vehicle expenses eat into profits. The constant driving means frequent refueling, accelerated maintenance schedules, and faster depreciation on your vehicle. 

These costs aren't immediately obvious but significantly reduce your effective hourly rate. 

After accounting for gas, maintenance, and depreciation, some drivers report net earnings dropping to $8-10 per hour.

No benefits whatsoever come with this independent contractor position. 

Health insurance, paid time off, retirement contributions, workers' compensation – these safety nets simply don't exist. 

If you get sick or injured, or your car breaks down, your income immediately stops until you can get back on the road.

Safety concerns are real. Long hours navigating traffic increases accident risk, and delivering to unfamiliar areas (sometimes at night) can put drivers in uncomfortable situations. 

Some drivers report dealing with hostile customers or delivering to unsafe locations with limited support from Uber.

Competition is fierce in many markets. Uber Eats continually onboards new drivers, which can dilute order volume for everyone. 

This leads to more waiting time between deliveries, cutting into potential earnings. 

The platform's algorithm may also batch multiple orders together ("stacked" deliveries), which often don't pay proportionally for the extra time and effort required.

Restaurants on Uber Eats: Expanded Reach vs. Squeezed Margins

Restaurant owners face perhaps the most complex decision when it comes to Uber Eats. 

Let's examine what they gain and give up by partnering with the platform.

The Upside for Restaurants

New customer exposure is the biggest draw. Culinary schools like Escoffier note that Uber Eats provides access to thousands of local users who might never discover your restaurant otherwise. 

For small or new establishments especially, this visibility can jumpstart awareness without traditional marketing costs.

Additional revenue streams help diversify business, particularly during slow in-house dining periods or inclement weather. 

During the pandemic, these online orders became lifelines for many restaurants that couldn't serve dine-in customers. 

Even now, delivery often represents incremental sales that wouldn't exist otherwise.

Ready-made delivery infrastructure saves restaurants from building their own delivery fleet. 

The logistics of hiring drivers, managing routes, and handling vehicle insurance are all handled by Uber. 

This turnkey approach lets restaurants focus on food preparation rather than delivery logistics.

In-app marketing opportunities can boost visibility further.

Restaurants can opt into promotional features like sponsored listings or limited-time deals to attract more customers. 

Uber Eats also provides data on popular dishes and peak ordering times, helping restaurants optimize their offerings.

Quick setup process gets restaurants online with minimal hassle. 

Uber provides the necessary technology (tablet or POS integration) and handles payment processing, making it relatively straightforward to start accepting delivery orders compared to building a proprietary system.

The Downside for Restaurants

Commission fees are staggering. Uber Eats typically charges restaurants 15-30% of each order value. 

For most restaurants operating on thin margins (5-10% is common in the industry), these fees can make delivery orders barely profitable or even money-losing propositions.

A $20 order might result in $6 going to Uber – often exceeding the restaurant's profit on that meal.

These high commission rates create a situation where restaurants sometimes work primarily to benefit the delivery company rather than themselves.

Customer relationship ownership shifts to Uber Eats. 

Restaurants don't receive customer contact information from app orders, preventing direct marketing for repeat business. 

This creates dependency on the platform as an intermediary rather than building direct customer relationships.

Brand experience control is limited. If a driver is late or unprofessional, customers still associate that negative experience with the restaurant. 

Food quality can deteriorate during delivery through no fault of the restaurant, yet they bear the brunt of customer dissatisfaction.

Operational complications arise when juggling in-house dining and delivery orders simultaneously. 

During rush periods, kitchen staff may become overwhelmed trying to manage both streams efficiently. 

Additionally, proper delivery packaging costs more than standard takeout containers, further cutting into margins.

Pricing dilemmas force difficult decisions. 

Restaurants must either raise menu prices on Uber Eats (potentially turning off customers with "too expensive" perceptions) or accept reduced profits on each order. 

This pricing predicament creates tension between staying competitive and remaining financially viable.

Is Uber Eats Worth It? Making Your Decision

Whether Uber Eats makes sense depends entirely on your situation:

For customers: Uber Eats works best as an occasional convenience rather than a daily habit. If you're too tired to cook, facing bad weather, or hosting a gathering where everyone wants different food, the convenience might justify the premium. 

But for regular meals, the significant markup makes it an expensive proposition.

If you're ordering frequently, check if restaurant online ordering systems might offer direct ordering with better pricing. 

Many establishments now offer their own delivery or pickup options with loyalty incentives to bypass third-party apps.

For drivers: Success hinges on strategic approaches. Focus on peak meal times (11am-1pm lunch and 5-9pm dinner) when orders flow steadily. 

Track all expenses meticulously for tax deductions.

Multi-apping (working for multiple delivery platforms simultaneously) often provides the most consistent income. 

Our comparison of food delivery platforms shows that Uber Eats typically pays more per order than competitors, though DoorDash dominates in order volume.

For restaurants: Consider Uber Eats as a marketing channel rather than a profit center. 

Use it to introduce new customers to your brand, then implement strategies to convert them to direct ordering. 

Carefully analyze which menu items maintain acceptable margins after commission and focus on promoting those.

Common Questions About Uber Eats

Is driving for Uber Eats actually profitable?

It can be, but requires strategy. 

Average earnings hover around $15-20 per hour before expenses. 

Once you factor in vehicle costs, effective earnings often drop to $10-15 per hour.

Success depends on working during peak demand periods, maintaining high ratings, and being selective about which orders to accept. 

Drivers in dense urban areas with higher tipping cultures generally fare better than those in suburban or rural locations.

Why does my Uber Eats order cost so much more than the menu price?

Your total can be up to 30-40% higher than ordering directly for several reasons. 

First, Uber Eats charges service fees (usually 15% of subtotal) and delivery fees ($0.99-$7.99 depending on distance and demand). 

Second, many restaurants raise their app prices to offset Uber's commission. 

Third, there's the tip for your driver.

For example, a $40 restaurant order might become $56 after a $6 service fee, $4 delivery fee, and $6 tip. 

Ordering directly from restaurants when possible can save you these extra charges.

How can restaurants make Uber Eats work financially?

Restaurants finding success with Uber Eats typically:

  • Optimize their menu specifically for delivery, focusing on items with higher margins and that travel well

  • Use data from Uber Eats to identify their most popular items and optimize pricing

  • Package marketing materials with orders to encourage direct ordering next time

  • Negotiate commission rates if they have sufficient volume or leverage with multiple platforms

  • Choose the lower-commission "pickup only" plan when possible

Making the Most of Food Delivery Platforms

Uber Eats, like most technology platforms, is ultimately a tool that can be used strategically or carelessly. 

The key is understanding the true costs and benefits for your specific situation.

For customers, it's about balancing convenience with financial sensibility. For drivers, it's about maximizing earning periods while tracking expenses. 

And for restaurants, it's about leveraging expanded reach while protecting margins.

The platform clearly works best when all three parties find value in the transaction – customers get food they enjoy delivered promptly, drivers earn reasonable compensation for their time and vehicle use, and restaurants gain incremental business without sacrificing profitability.

What's your experience with Uber Eats? 

Whether you're ordering, delivering, or serving, the real-world perspective is always more nuanced than any pros and cons list can capture.

Michael Leander

Michael Leander

Michael Leander

Senior Marketing Consultant

Michael Leander is an experienced digital marketer and an online solopreneur.

More in

Gig work

trends

A monthly post delivered straight to your inbox

Zero spam, just the good stuff

A monthly post delivered straight to your inbox

Zero spam, just the good stuff

A monthly post delivered straight to your inbox

Zero spam, just the good stuff